top of page
Search

Musk's Starlink and the Italian Honey "Moon"

Updated: Jan 16

Italy is currently exploring a highly coveted €1.5 billion deal with Elon Musk's SpaceX to utilize Starlink for secure government communications over a five-year period. This initiative aims to provide encrypted services for the Italian government, military, and emergency services and the deal is set to reshuffle the current European space ecosystem.


Musk sitting on a car with laptop, astronaut nearby, Italian flag, satellites, and a glowing celestial body in a starry sky. Text: "MUSK".
Musk and the Italian Honey Moon


The deal between Starlink and the Italy, not intended for commercial use by families and businesses but rather primarily utilised for governmental communications, include the following key points:


  1. The agreement focuses on providing encrypted satellite communication services for government officials, diplomats, and defense personnel, especially those working in high-risk areas;

  2. It aims to offer secure and advanced connectivity for Italy's military contingents around the world;

  3. The Italian government would retain full control over its data, despite utilizing U.S.-based technology;



Key Pillars of the Starlink-Italian government deal
Key Pillars of the Starlink-Italian Government Deal


Key Features of Starlink


Starlink is a satellite internet service operated by SpaceX, the aerospace company founded by Elon Musk. It aims to provide high-speed, low-latency broadband internet globally, particularly in areas with limited or no traditional internet infrastructure.


  1. Satellite Network:

    • Starlink consists of thousands of small satellites in Low Earth orbit (LEO), forming a constellation to deliver internet connectivity.

    • These satellites communicate with ground stations and user terminals to provide internet access.


  2. User Terminals:

    • Customers use a satellite dish and modem, known as a user terminal, to connect to the internet via Starlink's satellites.


  3. Global Coverage:

    • Starlink is designed to reach remote and underserved regions, such as rural areas, mountains, and islands, where traditional fiber or cellular networks are unavailable.


  4. High-Speed Internet:

    • Offers speeds ranging from 50 Mbps to 250 Mbps in its beta phase, with future plans to exceed 1 Gbps.

    • Low latency of 20-40 milliseconds


  5. Current Status:

    • Starlink has launched over 5,000 satellites since 2019 and continues to expand its constellation.

    • It serves both residential and commercial users and has applications in emergency services, maritime industries, and military communications.


  6. Future Goals:

    • Starlink aims to launch more satellites to increase capacity and improve service quality.

    • The network is integral to SpaceX's broader vision of funding missions to Mars by generating revenue from satellite internet services. Beyond just providing funding for SpaceX, Starlink technology is also being adapted for use on Mars. SpaceX is developing "Marslink," an extension of Starlink designed to provide internet connectivity on the Red Planet.This system could offer high-speed data relay capabilities between Earth and Mars, supporting future colonization efforts and scientific research.



    Starlink system features
    Starlink system's main features

Starlink represents a significant technological advancement in global internet access, with potential to bridge the digital divide and connect billions of people worldwide. However, challenges such as regulatory hurdles, space debris management, and competition remain critical areas of focus.



Differences between EU-IRIS2 and US-Starlink


IRIS² and Starlink are both satellite internet constellations, but they differ significantly in several aspects:


1. Number of satellites: IRIS² will consist of 290 satellites, while Starlink has already deployed over 7,000 satellites.


2. Orbital configuration: IRIS² will use a multi-orbital approach, combining Low Earth Orbit (LEO) and Medium Earth Orbit (MEO) satellites. Starlink primarily operates in LEO.


3. Coverage area: IRIS² is designed to cover Europe and its specific needs, whereas Starlink aims for global coverage.


4. Purpose: IRIS² focuses on providing secure connectivity for EU governments, businesses, and citizens, while Starlink primarily targets consumer broadband services.


5. Development stage: IRIS² is still in development, with full operational status expected by 2030. Starlink is already operational and serving millions of users worldwide.


6. Funding and ownership: IRIS² is a European Union initiative with public-private partnerships, while Starlink is a private venture by SpaceX.


7. Capacity and latency: IRIS²'s multi-orbital approach aims to balance coverage and latency, potentially offering more capacity in certain markets where Starlink might struggle to meet demand.


8. Environmental impact: IRIS² plans to use fewer satellites, potentially reducing space debris and visual impact compared to Starlink's larger constellation.




Differences between Iris2 and Starlink
Main Differences Between European IRIS2 & Starlink



Key reasons pushing Musk to enter the Italian market



Elon Musk eating Spaghetti
Elon Musk eating spaghetti. Courtesy of Andrea Stroppa


Elon Musk's push to enter the Italian market with the Starlink deal appears to be driven by several strategic reasons:


  1. Expanding Starlink's European presence: The deal would mark Starlink's first major contract with an EU government, potentially opening doors for similar agreements with other European countries.


  2. Gaining a competitive edge: By securing a deal with Italy, Musk could position Starlink as a viable alternative to the EU's upcoming IRIS² satellite network, set to launch in 2029. This move could pressure the European space industry and telecommunications sector.


  3. Leveraging political connections: Musk's cordial relationship with Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and his support for President-elect Donald Trump may be facilitating these negotiations.


  4. Tapping into the defense and security market: SpaceX is developing Starshield, a project for defense and sensitive operations, which could be of interest to the Italian government.


  5. Establishing a foothold in EU's satellite communications: By potentially replacing or complementing existing systems, Musk could gain significant influence in Europe's satellite and telecommunications sectors.



    Pros and Cons of Starlink's entrance in Italy


By pursuing this deal, Musk appears to be positioning Starlink as a key player in global satellite communications, particularly in government and military sectors, while also expanding his influence in European affairs.



Starlink Presence in Africa


Starlink's entrance into the European market differs significantly from its presence in Africa in several key aspects:


Market Maturity and Competition

In Europe:


  • Starlink faces more established telecommunications infrastructure and competition;

  • The EU is developing its own satellite constellation, IRIS², as a direct competitor to Starlink;

  • European countries have existing satellite operators and space firms collaborating on projects like IRIS²;


In Africa:

  • Starlink often enters markets with less developed telecommunications infrastructure;

  • The company has rapidly expanded to 13 African countries since 2023, with plans for 25 more;


Strategic Approach

For Europe:

  • Starlink is focusing on securing government and military contracts to gain a foothold;

  • The company is negotiating deals with individual countries, such as the potential €1.5 billion agreement with Italy;


In Africa:

  • The approach is more focused on expanding general availability and addressing connectivity gaps for families and local businesses;

  • Partnerships with local companies, like Africa Mobile Networks in Nigeria, are being formed to enhance reach;


Starlink's commercial approach in Africa
Starlink's Pricing in Africa

Market Potential and Growth

Europe:


  • Starlink is projected to generate significant revenue, with estimates of $11.8 billion globally in 2025, including substantial government contracts;

  • The European market is seen as crucial for Starlink's growth, with the company aiming to "conquer" the region;


Africa:

  • The focus is on rapid expansion and addressing capacity issues in urban areas;

  • Starlink's growth in Africa is part of a broader strategy to provide connectivity in underserved regions.;


These differences reflect the distinct challenges and opportunities Starlink faces in each market, with Europe presenting a more competitive but potentially lucrative landscape, while Africa offers significant growth potential in less developed markets.



Italian Stance to Musk Starlink's Proposal


Based on this scenario, here are some potential counter-offers the Italian government should consider in negotiations with SpaceX:


  1. Equity Stake: The Italian government could propose acquiring a minority stake in SpaceX or its Starlink division in exchange for the contract. This would give Italy a vested interest in the company's success and potentially provide future returns.


  2. Technology Transfer: Italy could request SpaceX to share certain satellite or communication technologies with Italian aerospace companies, fostering domestic innovation and expertise.


  3. Local Manufacturing: The government might propose that SpaceX establish satellite or ground station manufacturing facilities in Italy, creating jobs and boosting the local economy.


  4. Research Collaboration: Italy could offer partnerships between SpaceX and Italian universities or research institutions, promoting scientific exchange and development.


  5. Launch Site Development: The Italian government might suggest developing a SpaceX launch site in Italy, enhancing Europe's space capabilities.


  6. Data Sovereignty Guarantees: In exchange for the contract, Italy could demand stronger data sovereignty assurances, including local data storage and processing facilities.


  7. Preferential Pricing: The government could negotiate discounted rates for future Starlink services for Italian citizens or businesses, expanding broadband access nationwide.


  8. Joint Venture: Italy might propose creating a joint venture between SpaceX and Italian aerospace companies for specific projects or services related to the contract.


    Strategic Negotiation for the Italy-Starlink Partnership


These counter-offers aim to maximize the benefits for Italy while addressing concerns about data sovereignty, local economic impact, and technological development.



Conclusions


In summary, while the proposed Starlink deal offers immediate benefits in terms of secure communications and connectivity for Italy, it also raises significant concerns regarding national security, European strategic autonomy, and political implications for all parties involved.




Want to know more about Partnerships and network with like-minded Alliance leaders? Join the Slack Community

 


Slack community

Discover how to strike a strategic partnership:




Author


Written by Gianluca Caccamo, leader in connecting People and Data for Strategic Partnerships, counting more than 15 years at companies like Google, Pinterest and Wix among others.




Citations:


[1] https://indianexpress.com/article/technology/tech-news-technology/iris-european-union-internet-satellite-service-elon-musk-starlink-rival-9731815/

[2] https://defence-industry-space.ec.europa.eu/commission-takes-next-step-deploy-iris2-secure-satellite-system-2024-12-16_en

[3] https://www.theverge.com/2024/12/16/24322358/iris2-starlink-rival-europe-date-cost

[4] https://en.meteorologiaenred.com/iris2-the-ambitious-european-satellite-project.html

[5] https://en.meteorologiaenred.com/iris2-the-european-constellation-that-promises-to-change-satellite-communication.html

[6] https://defence-industry-space.ec.europa.eu/eu-space/iris2-secure-connectivity_en

[7] https://www.pcmag.com/news/eu-officially-begins-work-on-11-billion-starlink-rival-iris2

[8] https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20241216141644/en/IRIS2-lifts-off-as-European-Commission-and-SpaceRISE-sign-contract-in-Brussels

[9] https://en.pitane.blue/2024/12/29/iris2-versus-starlink-europe-challenges-musk-with-its-own-satellite-network/amp/

[10] https://www.hispasat.com/en/press-room/press-releases/archivo-2024/475/spacerise-selected-by-european-commission-to-build-and-operate-the-iris2-multi-orbit-satellite-constellation

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page